What We Value, Part II: Design Projects
There are certain factors that have primary value in a design project layout and presentation. Some are quantifiable, and others more subjective.
(Since my focus is on commercial art and advertising, I have chosen to limit this essay to that arena, rather than exploring the impact and value of fine arts such as painting or the professions of architecture and fashion design. I do draw inspiration from those fields, and may explore such related topics in the future.)
So then: What has value in a design presentation? Usability, effectiveness, relevance and relatability, balance, and creativity are the guidelines I use when evaluating both my own work and the creative projects I come across in everyday life, where multimedia design is encountered at every turn.
Usability in design is quantifiable. A test group of website visitors can be a guideline as to how sensible the navigation would be for the average user. Is it easy to locate and view the information they are interested in? Do they immediately comprehend the purpose of the page, the products or services offered, the identity or mission of the company whose web-presence this is?
When a clearly defined “call to action” (CTA) is directly tied to the presentation itself, the number of individuals who view the design layout and then follow through with the desired response (by perhaps purchasing products on the site or providing an email address to sign up for a newsletter’s mailing list) can be measured as the quantifiable result of an effective presentation.
In a print media example, the layout and copy of a magazine ad page is
most user-friendly when it is highly legible, easily processed and understood. A quantifiable response, for determining if a print campaign is compelling, could be tracking how many customers bring in the coupon included in the ad when making a store purchase.
Therefore, as designers, having insight into the thought process and likely actions of the viewers of our work is crucial in deciding how to present content for maximum usability and intended results.
So when starting the work on any project, prior to presenting any stage of the results to stakeholders, there should be an exploratory stage which includes forming an understanding of the potential audience. Research and an openminded discovery process is the professional approach to beginning any commercial art endeavor.
Developing a clear idea of what is relevant to your target market, which design concepts might resonate, and which copywriting and presentation styles would be approachable: these are the keys to creating a workable solution. During this development stage, many trial concepts might be prepared, reworked, or discarded before a truly appropriate strategy is found.
Effective design layouts should serve as a springboard. Once your eyes land on the printed page, the website, the packaging, the billboard: Are you compelled? To go forth and buy the product, or investigate the source of this intriguing presentation? Do you want to read further, and know more? If you can’t imagine that what you’re offering might be energizing, fascinating, satisfying, or thought-provoking, the approach will be missing the mark.
It would then have little value, no matter how appropriate it might seem for your client’s brand or their shareholder’s preferences. So it’s worthy to consider whether the look and feel of the project not only reflects the company’s identity but also relates to the interests of the intended audience.
Whether a presentation is eye-catching, appealing, startling, soothing,
or has visual impact in any way is highly subjective.
We all have different emotional reactions, outlooks and personal tastes. For instance, one individual may value conservative colors used sparingly to highlight important details, combined with well-known fonts and serene landscape photography. Another may see a vividly colored layout with action-oriented images as an exciting invitation to become part of the latest craze.
While these preferences definitely affect our sense of what a balanced design layout is, it’s fairly universal that people will respond negatively to a crowded, jumbled page. Knowing when to incorporate symbolic elements, such as lines, or differently textured backgrounds to separate or highlight certain areas, are skills of the experienced commercial artist. Providing a few key areas of interest, while keeping layout principles (including well- distributed visual weight, symmetry, and careful use of asymmetry) in mind, can result in a favorable reception to your work.
So as a designer, I endeavor to strike a balance:
between dynamic and static,
positive (filled) space and negative (white) space,
copy and imagery,
pleasing and informing,
provoking and reassuring,
questioning and problem-solving.
It’s all part of the challenge to create something useable, relatable, interesting (and perhaps even innovative) with content and the way it is presented.
As artists, we often long to bring forth something new, different, a twist on the familiar. While it’s said that all art is derivative and we learn by copying, design work which is notable usually brings something previously unseen to our attention. Creativity has great importance in the field of design, but artistic expression shouldn’t be the primary consideration in commercial projects: the focus is on presenting an effective solution, our goal more than simply putting the images of our imagination on the page for their own sake.
There will be occasions where it is appropriate to bring your own voice to the project, if it will be in alignment with the brand identity or established guidelines. But it is valuable to remember that in every instance, even when your creations do not reflect your personal preferences or do not give you a chance to use ideas that long to see fruition, your work will still be a voice (for an idea, a product, a cause). Figuring out what form of creative problem-solving and artistry is suitable requires careful contemplation of both the project specifications, and your own goals and values as a designer.
